Tools for Scouting

GuidesCamps and the outdoorsUpdated 19 November 2026

Knives for Scouts: penknives v bushcraft knives, safety, care and sharpening

Most Scouts start with a penknife, and most bushcraft is easier with a fixed blade. The two do different jobs, the law treats them differently, and both are only as safe as the way they’re used and looked after.

This guide compares them, then covers knife safety, cleaning and sharpening, drawn from Scouts’ knife safety guidance, its Survival Skills knife pack, GOV.UK and the makers’ own care advice. It’s a summary for volunteers and parents, not legal advice.

The short answer

Knives and the law

GOV.UK sets out the rules. In short, it’s illegal to:

The exception to both the carrying and the selling rule is a folding pocketknife with a cutting edge of 3 inches or less that doesn’t lock (no button, spring or catch you have to use to fold it). A lock knife isn’t a ā€œfolding pocketknifeā€ in law, however short its blade. Some knives, such as flick knives and butterfly knives, are banned outright.

The penalty for an adult carrying a knife illegally is up to four years in prison, an unlimited fine, or both. The law changes, so check GOV.UK before buying for a group.

Penknife, lock knife or bushcraft knife

Penknife (non-locking)Lock knife or multi-toolBushcraft (fixed blade)
What it isA small folding knife, often with other tools (a Swiss Army Knife or similar), and no lockA folding knife whose blade locks open, including most multi-tools and Opinels with the locking ringOne solid blade fixed in the handle, carried in a sheath
Carrying it in publicAllowed without a reason if the cutting edge is 3 inches (7.62 cm) or lessNeeds a good reason, whatever the blade lengthNeeds a good reason, whatever the blade length
Selling it to under-18sAllowed (3 inches or less, no lock)Not allowedNot allowed
Best forCutting string, food prep, first whittling, the awl, saw and scissorsBigger whittling and cutting jobs where you still want something that foldsCarving, feather sticks, firewood prep and batoning: most bushcraft
The safety catchThe blade can fold back onto the fingers if it's pushed the wrong wayCan't fold onto the fingers while lockedCan't fold at all, and a finger guard stops the hand sliding forward
SharpeningFiddly on a small blade: a pocket sharpener or a stoneDepends on the grindEasy on a Scandi grind: lay the bevel flat on the stone

Penknives are the natural first knife. Scouts’ pack says smaller ones without a lock shouldn’t be used for whittling large pieces or splitting wood, because the blade can fold back. Practise opening and closing first: pinch the blade and keep hold of it until it’s fully open or fully closed, and only open one tool at a time.

Lock knives are safer to work with than a penknife for the same reason they’re harder to carry: the blade stays put. Some multi-tools lock, so check before treating one as a penknife.

Fixed-blade bushcraft knives are the right tool for most bushcraft. Scouts’ pack finds them less good for fine detail than a small blade, so many groups use both: a penknife for detail and string, a fixed blade for carving and firewood.

What to look for

In a penknife:

In a bushcraft knife:

As an example of a range sized for young people, here are three Morakniv knives, from the manufacturer and retailer listings:

KnifeBladeNotes
Morakniv RookieAbout 7.2 cmMade for children: a very rounded tip, a finger guard, a small handle and a plastic sheath
Morakniv Scout 398.6 cmStainless steel and a double finger guard; a step up for older Scouts
Morakniv CompanionAbout 10.4 cmThe classic adult bushcraft knife, in stainless or carbon steel; big enough for batoning

All three are fixed blades, so all need a good reason to carry and can’t be sold to under-18s: they belong in the group’s kit, not a Scout’s pocket. Other makers sell similar knives. We haven’t tested any of them, and we’re not paid to mention them.

Knife safety

Before the session, from Scouts’ guidance:

Using a knife:

Sheathing and passing:

Cleaning and care

Sharpening

A sharp knife is a safer knife. It cuts with less force and goes where it’s pointed; a blunt one crushes the wood and slips. To check, hold the edge towards a light and look along it: a blunt edge shows a thin silver line where it’s rounded off. Never test an edge with a finger.

Scouts’ pack says sharpening should be done under a leader’s supervision. Its method, for a fixed blade on a combination stone:

  1. Put the stone on a flat, stable surface, coarse side up, with plenty of oil (or water for a whetstone).
  2. Lay the knife at the near end with the edge facing away from you, and tilt it until the bevel sits flat on the stone. On a Scandi grind you can feel it settle.
  3. Push the blade away along the stone, sweeping it across so the whole edge is covered, with gentle pressure from your fingers near the edge but never over it. Lift the handle slightly as you reach the curve near the tip.
  4. Turn the knife over and draw it towards you on the far side. Shiny scratches show where metal has come off: if they don’t cover the whole bevel, adjust the angle.
  5. Keep going, a side at a time, until you can feel a slight burr where the two bevels meet. Then repeat on the fine side.
  6. Finish by stropping on the back of an old leather belt fixed to something solid: draw the knife spine-first along it, 10 to 15 strokes a side. It should then slice paper cleanly.

Penknives don’t have a wide bevel to lay flat. Victorinox says to sharpen at 15 to 20 degrees each side on a whetstone (a 30 to 40 degree edge), or use a pocket sharpener. A small hand-held sharpener is quickest for a box of group penknives. Serrated edges are sharpened from the flat side only.

For a badly damaged edge, a local knife sharpening service is safer than a bench grinder. The Survival Skills badge asks Scouts to show basic knife skills including safety and sharpening, so the explanation counts as much as the edge.

A group knife kit

Keeping track of the knife box

Quartermaster keeps your group’s kit list, including each knife’s condition and where it’s kept. Check the box out to the leader running the session, optionally against a camp and with a signature, and see what hasn’t come back. A stock take marks each knife present or missing, and ā€œReport an issueā€ records a chipped blade with a photo. Checking kit out.

Planning the bushcraft itself? Camp Planner starts each camp’s risk assessment with tools and fires already in it.

Free to start. Tools for Scouting is made by a Scout volunteer and isn’t part of The Scout Association.

Sources

All guides